STOP paying attention to how many followers you have

Last month we talked about ads, but this month we want to talk about what has to come before any ad spend: who's actually showing up for you…

This is one of the boldest calls we've made with an artist this year, and it's already paying off.

The problem

Our artist had a massive following on their main account, but it wasn't the audience their new music was made for. Only 7% of that following was 18 to 24, so every post and release landed in front of people who liked the artist but weren't going to connect with where the music was headed.

And it wasn't just the audience. Between talking with the artist, hearing the unreleased music, and seeing how little the posts were landing, it was clear the image had drifted too. It felt more like a costume than like the artist.

It doesn't matter how big your audience is: if the right people aren't showing up, you'll always feel disconnected from your fanbase, and your fanbase won't feel connected to you either.

The setup

So we started over on a brand new account. With a blank slate, the artist could show up as authentically as possible. We built the content on four pillars:

  1. Covers to get discovered. Familiar songs, reimagined, brought strangers in. One cover alone reached over 2.1 million views on Instagram.

  2. Test new songs before release. The new account became our testing ground for which songs were most promising with the actual target audience, and fan response helped pick the single. The very first teaser for it reached an audience that was 45% under 25, when only 20% of the account's followers were.

  3. Show the personality. Funny, honest, unpolished posts let people get to know the person behind the music.

  4. Showcase the musical strengths. Performance clips built around the moments where their voice really shines.

Then we repeated it over and over and let the data tell us what to make more of. Two numbers we checked every single week: how many of our views came from people who didn't follow yet (we never let it dip below about 75%), and share rate, because a share means someone liked it enough to pass it on.

Bringing fans into the conversation

We also used Laylo*, a tool that lets fans sign up for messages straight from an artist. It let us go direct: asking fans what they wanted to see, finding out why they were showing up, and rewarding them for engaging at that deeper level.

We started early, months before the single. First a secret demo, then cover requests, and more. So by the time the song was ready, we already had a foundation to build on. On release eve, the artist answered fans' questions, sent in through Laylo (so they had to be signed up), live on TikTok and Instagram. It gave fans a real reason to sign up, gave the artist something easy to talk about, and made the Live feel like a conversation instead of a broadcast.

The result

The new account went from zero to tens of thousands of followers in a matter of months. In the 30 days before release it grew 47% and reached 1.7 million views, and 84% of those views came from people who didn't follow yet (this is key!!!). Most importantly, 62% of its audience is 18 to 34, which is exactly who this music is for.

Then release week came:

  • 1,000 presaves before we spent a single dollar on ads, and over 2,100 by release day

  • Under $650 in TikTok ads for the whole campaign: presaves at $1.22 each, and about $0.40 per click through to a streaming service after release

  • The artist's day-one streaming record, broken by 8am Pacific

  • Over 100,000 streams in the first week

  • Nearly 8 streams per listener in the first week, which means people weren't just checking it out, they kept coming back to it, over and OVER (an ultimate signal to the Spotify algorithm)

  • Super listeners (Spotify's name for an artist's most engaged listeners) grew from about 770 to 2,547, from the day before release to the end of release week, and hit 3,212 two weeks in

  • Over 200 videos made with the song

  • Label interest, and the artist chose to stay independent for this release. As a team, we were confident we could make a splash without a label this time, and we did.

Making the bold call, again

The account restart wasn't the only time we followed the data. A few days into the presave ads, our new-listener audiences were costing about $3 per presave. We cut the weaker clips, costs dropped to about $1.10, and we more than doubled the budget on those audiences mid-campaign.

The fine print

The main account still played a part during release week, so this isn't a clean head-to-head between the two accounts. The real difference is who we're reaching: the smaller account is the one bringing in the listeners this next chapter is built on, and the main account worked more like a billboard to promote to a wider audience.

Our takeaways

Look at the data first. If you're consistently reaching the wrong people, any ad spend you add just reaches more of the wrong people. They won't come to your shows, buy your merch, or probably even stream your song once.

Build a brand that comes from you, not one built around what you think the industry is looking for.

Don't be afraid of the bold move. Starting over gave us a much smaller account, but as an asset it's worth far more than the bigger one.

Find ways to show up that feel sustainable and good for you, because consistency only works if you can keep it up.

Starting a new era or a release that needs the right audience behind it? Email us and tell us about it!! :)

Best,
Tori + Kelsy

*This is our referral link, which you can use to sign up for Laylo. We only share tools we actually use with our artists.

Next
Next

Our best ad was an old Instagram post