We've been running Meta ad campaigns for a few years now, and we are STILL seeing new takeaways each time we run a campaign.
So we thought we'd redesign our newsletter to tell you about the most successful campaigns we are running and WHY they are so successful.
It's ever-changing, almost as often as TikTok trends, and we absolutely love cracking the code time and time again.
For our first case study we want to share, we just ran this campaign a couple weeks ago and were shocked at our findings.
The problem
So ten days before a Monday night show in Portland, our artist had sold 22 tickets and hadn't spent anything on ads yet. (Mondays are hard, everyone knows this.)
We ran two campaigns for $378 total, and the show finished with a whopping 101 tickets… let's reiterate.. ON A MONDAY.
We thought it was a cool campaign that very obviously helped pack a room, so we wanted to share with you all what we did + what we learned.
The setup
We went in with three things we've seen work across a lot of past campaigns when running ads for shows specifically:
Live clips build connection. They give a stranger the feeling of being in the room.
Audiences who don't know the artist certainly don't want a sales pitch, so our discovery ads skip the "buy tickets" ask.
People who already know the artist are ready to be asked, so we ask them directly, in the artist's own voice.
None of that tells us which ad will win, though. So that's the part we test fresh every time.
Campaign 1: Discovery (new people in Portland)
Seven ads: fan-filmed live clips, tripod-style live shots, different songs, music video clips and "for fans of" angles.
None of these ads had a call to action. We gave them a few days to test, then moved the budget to what was working.
On day five we added an eighth ad. It was an old organic post that had done well: fan-filmed, with a native Tiktok font, so it looked like it belonged in the feed.
It took over almost right away.
Cost per click: 8.7 cents vs 14.1 cents for the other seven combined
Result: 565 people to the artist's site for $69 (about 12 cents each)
Campaign 2: Conversion (people who already know the artist)
One ad with one goal: get them to the ticket page.
The copy on the ad said "You're invited" instead of "Get tickets," and a regional press quote came in near the end of the video.
We started at $40 and raised the budget three times in three days ($40 → $80 → $180 → $310).
Cost per ticket-page visit: 59 cents on day one, about 12 cents by day four, and it stayed there
Result: 2,163 people to the ticket page for $309 (14 cents avg)
The result
22 tickets sold → 80 by Sept 12 → and ultimately 101 final.
That's 79 added tickets, roughly $1,580 in gross sales, or about $4 back for every $1 spent.
The fine print
The winning ad joined on day five, so it's not a perfect side-by-side with the other ad creatives. The conversion campaign only had one ad because there was no time to test a second. And ads weren't the only thing selling tickets, so treat that $4 as a ceiling.
Our takeaways
Test everything. The winning ad was one we never would have picked on day one.
Dig through your old posts. Our best ad already existed. We just had to go find it. HINT: Choose your best performing live clip.
Feeling first, ask second. Show new people the atmosphere of a live show. Save the direct ask for the ones who already know you.
The final week isn't too late. Playing a Monday instead of a Friday can feel like it decides everything, but with some budget + a plan you can still get people out.
It works best if you've been building all along. Keep your Meta pixel active, keep posting and keep growing the audience. Then when it's crunch time, you already have a warm group ready to hear from you.
Got a release or tour coming up? Email us and tell us about it!! :)
Best,
Tori + Kelsy